I have tried a bunch of copycat recipes to get my "fix" but this combo of Cafe Rio dishes is my favorite. You can make a lot of it ahead of time so it was great to eat right after John's game.
Café Rio Pork
(a mix between Sheri Denney and Martha McMullin's recipes)
7-8 lbs. pork roast (Do a 3-4 lb pork roast if you are just doing your family)
4 cups root beer
5 (8oz) cans tomato sauce
4 T molasses or honey
3 tsp. minced garlic
½ tsp. salt
2 - 3 cups brown sugar
pepper to taste
4 tsp. cumin
Recipe Note: The above sauce makes a ton! So if you have a 3-4 lb pork roast, half the sauce.
Salt and pepper roast and cook in crock pot 8 hours or overnight on low in water. In the morning remove the roast from the crockpot and pull apart with fork, removing fat. Drain all the water in the crockpot. Don't overshred the pork or it will turn mushy. Add the rest of the ingredients to the crockpot and add shredded pork. Cook another 4 hours in crockpot on low.
Café Rio Chicken
5 lbs chicken breast, boneless, skinless
1 sm bottle zesty italian dressing
1 T chili powder
1 T cumin
3 cloves garlic, minced
Mix all ingredients together in a large crock pot. Cook on high for 5-7 hours. Remove chicken and shred. Reserve a small amount of juice and pour over shredded chicken. Keep warm.
Café Rio Lime Cilantro Rice
(Double this for large crowd)
2 Tb. Butter
pepper to taste
1 ¼ rice
juice and zest 1 large or 2 small limes
2 ¼ cups chicken broth
2 Tb. chopped cilantro
¾ tsp. salt
¼ tsp. cumin
In a skillet melt butter with rice, add liquid, and other ingredients. Bring to a boil, reduce heat, cover and cook for 20 minutes.
Pico de Gallo
5 plum tomatoes
1/2 large or small red onion
3 jalapenos (optional)
cilantro
lime juice
salt
Quantities are approximate
Chop jalapenos, onion, and tomatoes in a very small dice. Leave seeds in your jalapenos for a hotter pico. Adjust the amount of jalapenos for your preferred temperature. Next, chop up a nice-sized bunch of cilantro. Disregard the long stems before chopping. Stir together. Add the juice of a half a lime and add salt to taste.
Tomatillo Dressing
1 pkg Hidden Valley Ranch Dressing mix
1 C buttermilk
1 C Mayo
1 to 2 tomatillos
1 clove garlic, minced
1/2 bunch cilantro, chopped
1/2 t lime juice
1/2 to 1 small jalapeno, seeds removed.
Blend all together in a blender or food processor and store in the refrigerator to let the flavors meld.
For salads serve in the following order:
tortillas (I warm mine in foil pans like cafe rio in the oven with cheese)
cheese
black or pinto beans
lime rice
shredded chicken or pork
red and green leaf lettuce, shredded
sprinkle crunch corn strips on top
grated Parmesan cheese
sides of:
pico de gallo
guacamole
fresh cilantro
fresh lime slice
tomatillo dressing


















Can I tell you how much I love your recipe blog. I have a friend who saw it from my blog and she made your chicken tortilla soup last night for enrichment. I will try these recipes, they are similar to what I use but I see some differences. Do you get the tortillas from Costco? They are the best!
I love it to! Me and Royce have missed it so much we want to open a costa vida I know not as goo but they franchise! I going to try these reciepes for sure! Thanks You are great!
We too have had to resort to making our own Cafe Rio Pork Salads. They have been so yummy and always a hit when we invite people who have lived in Provo before. Bob loves to make this!
Question: For your pork recipe, how many oz of tomato sauce do I need?
I am so excited! The recipe I have takes coke, and I love the idea of using root beer instead. Thanks for these recipes!
Hey Christy! I dont know if you remember me from our old ward in Provo? Anyways Nicole Goggins told me about your amazing food blog. I love it! your such an awesome cook! I make the cafe rio salad all the time but the only problem I have is that whenever I make the dressing its really runny not as thick as the actual cafe rio dressing. Is yours the same way? just curious if Im doing it wrong or if thats just how it is? Tastes great though! Thanks! And hope everything is going well with you and your family!
Hello. I just wanted to let you know that I made this recipe today and blogged it. But not to worry because I gave you the credit. You can check it out here, http://sweetteaandporchswings.blogspot.com/2010/11/brown-sugar-pork-roast.html.
I love your blog by the way and haven't even had a chance to save all the yummy recipes yet. Yum!
Very nice blog and I think this'll be my next recipe... seriously, I will do my best effort to make it alone but I guess it's going to be difficult because this is my first time in this culinary blog. 23jj
Cafe Rio has been rumored to be starting a small chain in the VA and DC areas!!! I am super excited!
We made this tonight and it was amazing!
@Allie,
I totally remember you. Just saw this comment sorry...years later. The dressing is runnier than cafe rios but it depends how much water your tomatillos have in them I think.
They have a cafe rio in Virginia and Maryland.
Caferio.com/locations
I moved from Salt Lake about a year ago and I'm CONSTANTLY craving Cafe Rio! Thanks for the recipes!!