An Apple a Day

Apple Crisp Pizza

My husband's favorite dessert is a warm apple crisp with a huge scoop of vanilla ice cream. A couple of year ago we crowned this the Perfect Apple Crisp at least according to my husband's standards. But ...

Read More

Apple Pudding Cake with Cinnamon Butter Sauce

I love September because we finally get a break from the wretched heat here in Florida. I took adavantage of the low 80's weather and went for a morning run. Running is my therapy. It's ...

Read More

Apple Muffins

We are down to one laptop again so I haven't been able to post anything. John's busy doing taxes so I guess he gets priority on the laptop. Remember when I shamelessly begged for your recipes...well ...

Read More

Caramel Apple Cider Cookies

I've been avoiding blogging because I'm not sure the last few weeks of a crazy pregnant women should be documented. You don't really want to know that instead of craving chocolate I've been craving Glade Clean ...

Read More

Apple Streusel Coffee Cake

This morning I was commiserating with some fellow food bloggers on Instagram about how life as a food blogger is a constant struggle between doing what we love and trying to not to blow up ...

Read More

Caramel Apple Cheesecake Bars

These Caramel Apple Cheesecake Bars are the most popular recipe on my blog and have been pinned over 1 million times. These creamy cheesecake bars are topped with diced apples and a streusel topping. I can't believe it's ...

Read More

Caramel Apple Cupcakes

September is finally here and all I can think about are all of the apple recipes I want to dig into. I've already lit my fall candles to get in the mood since we kind of have to ...

Read More

Apple Pie Caramel Apple

I know this recipe isn't complicated or even a recipe really but it's that time of year and this caramel apple deserves to be made. These remind me of can find the most delicious ...

Read More

Key Lime Pie On A Stick

This Key Lime Pie On A Stick dessert was inspired by our many trips to the Florida Keys where they sell slices of key lime pie dipped in chocolate and frozen. This homemade version is a little smaller and perfectly portioned. Don’t be intimidated. It’s way easier than you think!
Key Lime Pie on a Stick | The Girl Who Ate Everything
You know you’re a food blogger when you decide you want to make Key Lime Pie bars and you already have everything you need. Labor Day is the official end of summer. It makes me so sad. I embrace the beach days with no schedules. I thought I would squeeze one more summer treat in before I bring on the soups and casseroles.

We’re an hour and a half from the Florida Keys and take advantage of the tropical atmosphere as often as we can. At certain gas stations along the long road down to the keys they sell slices of key lime pie, frozen, and dipped in Belgian chocolate. They are one of my favorite treats ever. I realize that not everyone is a fan of the tart key lime pie but if you are, you will appreciate this dessert.

Key Lime Pie on a Stick | The Girl Who Ate EverythingI used this key lime juice. They sell it by the lemon and regular lime juice. You could definitely squeeze it yourself with fresh key limes but they’re not available in all areas. You could even use regular limes but it won’t be quite as potent.

Key Lime Pie on a Stick | The Girl Who Ate Everything

Start by making your key lime pies. I started with my favorite graham cracker crust and then filled it with the easiest key lime pie filling ever – only 3 ingredients. I bake mine for 15 minutes and they were perfect. Using cupcake tins is the perfect way to make small versions of the key lime pie. I’m sure you could make an actual pie and then slice it but that seemed way too involved. You could probably get away with not using paper liners but I thought it made it easier.

Key Lime Pie on a Stick | The Girl Who Ate Everything

After the’ve set up in the freezer for a little bit, I took off the wrapper and stuck the popsicle sticks in the center.

Key Lime Pie on a Stick | The Girl Who Ate Everything

Place them on a cookie sheet and return them to the freezer for a couple of hours to firm up.

Key Lime Pie on a Stick | The Girl Who Ate Everything

You can use any melting chocolate you want. I started with a tub of Baker’s melting chocolate but only had enough to dip 6. Then I used some melted chocolate chips with some oil  mixed together and it yielded a really nice, thin consistency for dipping. So either way works!

Key Lime Pie on a Stick | The Girl Who Ate Everything

Let them set up in the freezer. You can use wax paper…or not. I tried both ways and there didn’t seem to be a big difference.

Key Lime Pie on a Stick | The Girl Who Ate Everything

Isn’t it gorgeous?

Key Lime Pie on a Stick | The Girl Who Ate Everything

And the crust to filling ratio…perfect.

Key Lime Pie On A Stick

Yield: Makes 12


  • 1 1/4 cups graham cracker crumbs
  • 2/3 cup butter, melted
  • 3 Tablespoons brown sugar
  • Filling:
  • 1 (14 oz) can sweetened condensed milk
  • 3 egg yolks
  • 1/2 cup key lime juice
  • Chocolate coating:
  • 1 1/2 cups milk or semi-sweet chocolate chips
  • 1/3 cup vegetable oil


  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees and line a cupcake tin with 12 paper liners.
  2. In a medium bowl, mix the graham cracker crumbs, melted butter, and brown sugar until combined. Place 1-2 tablespoons of the mixture into each of the 12 cupcake tins. Press down firmly. I used the bottom of a 1/4 measuring cup to press the crust into the tin.
  3. In a medium bowl, combine the sweetened condensed milk, egg yolks, and key lime juice until smooth.
  4. Pour about 1/4 cup of the filling on top of the graham cracker crust in each tin. Bake for 15 minutes. Let pies cool for about 10 minutes and then place them in the freezer for at least 2 hours. After pies have chilled, remove the paper liners and place a popsicle stick in the center of each pie. Return pies to a cookie sheet and freeze for at least another 3-4 hours. Once pies are thoroughly frozen, dip them in melting chocolate. You can use store bough melting chocolate or make your own.
  5. For the dipping chocolate: In a small deep bowl, melt the chocolate chips and oil in the microwave in 30 second intervals, stirring in between until melted. Dip the pies in the chocolate completely covering the pie. I found it easier to use a spoon and kind of drizzle it over the pies. Gently shake as much excess chocolate off as you can and lay the pies on the cookie sheet. Return pies to the freezer until chocolate has set up and you are ready to eat. The pies will be good in the refrigerator for at least 2 weeks if not longer. Enjoy!


Source: Crust and chocolate by me, filling base from the back of the Nellie and Joe's Key Lime Pie Juice bottle.

Schema/Recipe SEO Data Markup by ZipList Recipe Plugin

Heavenly Morsels - 3 ingredient cookies | The Girl Who Ate Everything

Heavenly Morsels

These Heavenly Morsels are made up of only 3 ingredients and little pieces of heaven. They have a chewy outside with a soft center with loads of gooey … [Read More...]

Mini Taco Stuffed Peppers - mini bell peppers stuffed with taco meat and drizzled with a cilantro cream sauce. {The Girl Who Ate Everything}

Mini Taco Stuffed Peppers

These Mini Taco Stuffed Peppers are miniature bell peppers stuffed with taco meat and drizzled with a cilantro cream sauce. They can easily be made … [Read More...]

Elephant Ears | The Girl Who Ate Everything

Elephant Ears

Named for their shape, these Elephant Ears are layers of puff pastry with cinnamon and sugar. Only four ingredients to make this tasty treat. My … [Read More...]


Barn Owl Primitives Giveaway

This giveaway is over and the winners have been contacted. I'm so excited for this giveaway today. Growing up my mom had different sayings on the … [Read More...]

Blueberry Custard Pie | The Girl Who Ate Everything. A creamy blueberry custard topped with a sweet streusel.

Blueberry Custard Pie

This Blueberry Custard Pie is a twist on the classic blueberry pie with a creamy custard filling and topped with a crunchy streusel. With minimal … [Read More...]

Banana Bread Cookies | The Girl Who Ate Everything. Moist cake-like banana cookies with mini chocolate chips and nuts that taste just like banana bread.

Banana Bread Cookies

These Banana Bread Cookies are soft, moist, and full of banana flavor. You can add mini chocolate chips and nuts if you like. Just like any banana … [Read More...]