Lemon Drop Cookies


Spring has Sprung.
Backyard baseball games…
Limitless popsicles to combat the heat…
Neighbor friends staying for dinner…
And hoses attacking small children for no reason at all…


For one of my favorite times of the year, I’ve found a cookie that pretty much
squeezes all of that fun and sunshine into a mouthful.


Just like this…
Marco Island – March 2011

I’ve had these bookmarked forever. I saw them over at See Jane Cook and something about the texture of the cookies had me hooked. They are a chewy lemon cookie with crushed lemon drops in the cookie! Don’t try to substitute butter in this recipe. Trust me. I tried. They still tasted great but were flat as could be. I’ve made these three times in the last week so I guess that tells you how much I liked them.

Lemon Drop Cookies
Prep Time
21 hrs 59 mins
Cook Time
21 hrs 59 mins
  • Ingredients:
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 1 1/2 cups butter flavored shortening
  • 3 eggs
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla
  • 1 teaspoon lemon extract
  • 4 cups flour
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons baking soda
  • 1 1/2 teaspoons baking powder
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • Finely chopped zest of one lemon
  • 1 6-oz package lemon drops
  • 2 cups powdered sugar
  • juice of two lemons about 4-5 Tablespoons (I use less because I like my glaze a little thicker)
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees. In mixing bowl, cream sugar, shortening, and eggs; add vanilla and lemon extract. Stir in flour, baking soda, baking powder, and salt. Crush lemon drops in blender or food processor. Add lemon zest and crushed lemon drops. Roll into balls, flatten slightly with your hand, and bake on a parchment lined cookie sheet (You must use parchment here to avoid sticking).
  2. Bake for 10 to 12 minutes. Let cool slightly on pan for a couple of minutes. Make the glaze by mixing powdered sugar with lemon juice to desired consistency. Brush glaze over cookie tops after cookies have cooled slightly. If the cookies are too hot the glaze will just melt off. Let cookies cool completely.

Speak Your Mind



  1. Awesome pictures! When I was pregnant I craved lemons and lemon drop candies all the time, these would have hit the spot.

  2. My family vacations in Marco Island every year — my parents and brother were there in March as well! Love it there…

  3. I also found this recipe from See Jane Cook and my 12 year old daughter made them for a baking competition! She won first place, with over 30 entries to compete against!

    They are so delicious and such a crowd pleaser!!!

  4. oooooh so tasty, fresh and PERFECT for spring. Why is it that lemon is simply BETTER in the springtime!?!?

  5. I would love to make those! Lemon drops used to be my favorites candies (aside from chocolate that is)but I can never find them any more. All I ever see are those Lemon Head things. =(

  6. These sound delicious! I will try them soon. Thanks for sharing. ๐Ÿ™‚


  7. These are one of my favorite cookies. They look fabulous! I created a butter version I posted last summer.

  8. I felt a little famous when I saw ME on YOUR amazing blog! Thanks for the mention. I am glad you like these as much as I do.

  9. These look AMAZING. I’m throwing a baby shower this month and I am absolutely making these!!!

  10. These look fabulous! I adore anything lemon. I made lemon sugar cookies about a year ago, but I love the idea of a version with lemon drops in them!

    – Maggie

  11. I went to 2 stores today looking for lemon drop candies…no luck! Total bummer cause after looking at your picture, I’m craving these cookies.

  12. @tease-spoon of sugar,
    Oh no! My Publix grocery store always has them and so does my SuperTarget. Shoot.

  13. These just sound amazing!! unfortunately i am the only lemon person in the house!! maybe i will make a few just for myself :D. Loads of love for spring !!

  14. These sound great, I love lemon! Will add them to my make list.

  15. I love lemon. Seriously, it’s one of the only things I crave when I’m pregnant. I’ll have to remember these cookies.

  16. These look and sound super tasty. I love lemon drops!

  17. I love your blog, I use your recipes probably every week but have never posted. I made these yesterday and they were wonderful! (they did turn out a little flat, but that’s okay ๐Ÿ™‚ As for finding lemon drops, I couldn’t find mine at the grocery store, but did find them at the gas station ๐Ÿ™‚

  18. OK going to find lemon drop candies tomorrow…if kids weren’t on their way to bed I’d be going out tonight! YUM!!

  19. I’m your newest follower and can’t believe I’ve just not stumbled upon your blog! I’ve already picked out 4 of your recipes to make…this one included! =)

  20. I am really loving lemon-anything lately! These look great! Thanks for sharing ๐Ÿ™‚ Guess I need to pick up some shortening!

  21. These look fresh! Usually i do not prepair cookies during the summer but i ‘ll try these cookies!!
    Yr blog is lovely, you posted great photos and recipes !!

  22. These look fresh! Usually i do not prepair cookies during the summer but i ‘ll try these cookies!!
    Yr blog is lovely, you posted great photos and recipes !!

  23. I love everything lemon and these look delicious. And cute. That’s important too ๐Ÿ˜‰

  24. What a fun cookie!

  25. any suggestions as to why my cookies weren’t as fluffy as yours? Mine were flat and a little crispy…They also really spread out during baking. I couldn’t put a full dozen on my pan.They were however still a crowd pleaser and super yummy. Thanks again for yet another amazing recipe!!

  26. @Heather,
    Not sure why they were so flat. The first two times I tried them using all butter, then partial butter and they were really flat. Is your baking powder old maybe?
    Did you use partial butter?

  27. Hey Christy~
    LOVE, LOVE, LOVE your blog! You have such yummy looking and tasting recipes on here! And I love the picture of little Mr. W, he is so stinkin’ cute. Now I’m officially a follower of your awesome blog! Take care lady!

  28. Ohhh my! These sound heavenly!

    Bookmarked to try! xo

  29. Argh! I haven’t popped in for a little bit… and there are so many goodies, I just hardly know where to start! These sound like they’d be great to bake and share with co-workers and a friend who lost her husband a few months ago. Thanks, Christy!

  30. thanks for responding. I didn’t use butter, I heeded your counsel on the shortening. ๐Ÿ™‚ my soda was new, but I am wondering how old my baking powder is? Oh well I am trying them again easter sunday. Yum yum

  31. I must admit that lemons and chocolate usually run neck and neck with me.

    These. Are. To. Die. For!!!!

    I’m so gald I found you, chicken gyros are next.

  32. I made these last week and they were great! They remind me of the lemon chip cookies from King Soopers when I was a kid. You’ll have to try one the next time you are in CO.

    I looked all over town for lemon drops. Then my brother told me to go to a drug store because they are “old people candy”. He was right!

  33. I made these for a family vacation- I am a die hard chocolate lover and my husband a snicker doodle lover- we now have a new favorite- stayed soft for days! Thanks for sharing!

  34. Nice for good sound.
    Sugar Free Lemon Drops Candy

  35. Just made these and used butter. It works just fine, you just need to bake at a lower temperature

  36. Coming back for the third Christmas for your lemon drop cookie recipe. I follow your instructions exactly. They are loved by many, and I have had many requests for the recipe. Thank You!