Pecan Pie Muffins

These Pecan Pie Muffins are a mix between a pie and a muffin. They have a muffin texture with a soft gooey inside like a pecan pie.

For a second I had the idea of giving you guys a beautiful step by step tutorial on how to make the perfect Thanksgiving turkey. But quite frankly making a turkey still terrifies me even though I’ve done it several times. The actual process isn’t that hard but if you screw up the bird, Thanksgiving is ruined. In my nightmare I imagine everyone sitting around a huge table staring sadly at their empty plates and then at me.

I’m not so much worried about a dry turkey because with a little gravy, almost any turkey is edible. My biggest fear is everyone showing up for dinner and having to wait a couple of hours to eat because I didn’t calculate my cooking time correctly and my turkey is raw.

Sooooo, instead I’m sharing some Pecan Pie Muffins that a reader Tammy sent me. I want to call these Puffins because they’re pie/muffins. I felt like they were more pie than muffin but my husband felt the opposite. These are super easy to throw together with only five ingredients. Tammy said if you just under-bake them, they really taste like a pecan pie and she’s right. I managed to eat more than I should have. They have crispy chewy edges and a soft gooey center.

These Pecan Pie Muffins are a mix between a pie and a muffin. They have a muffin texture with a soft gooey inside like a pecan pie. the-girl-who-ate-everything.com

Pecan Pie Muffins | The Girl Who Ate Everything

If you’re scared of butter you should just walk away now. Just sayin’. The only way you can screw these up is to not properly grease your pan. Baker’s Joy spray works really well here.These Pecan Pie Muffins are a mix between a pie and a muffin. They have a muffin texture with a soft gooey inside like a pecan pie. the-girl-who-ate-everything.com

Pecan Pie Muffins

8 large muffins or 16 mini muffins

Source: given to me by Tammy and adapted from Allrecipes

Ingredients

  • 1 cup packed light brown sugar
  • ½ cup all-purpose flour
  • 2 cups chopped pecans
  • 2/3 cup butter, softened
  • 2 eggs, beaten

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Grease mini or regular muffin cups generously. Grease them well or they will stick. In medium bowl, stir together brown sugar, flour and pecans. In a separate bowl, beat the butter and eggs together. Stir in dry ingredients just until combined.
  2. Spoon batter into muffin cups about 2/3 full. Bake for 12-13 minutes for mini muffins or 15-17 minutes for regular size muffins. Run a knife around the edge of each muffin and pop it out.
http://www.the-girl-who-ate-everything.com/2012/11/pecan-pie-muffins.html

Make sure you’re following The Girl Who Ate Everything for the latest recipes!

Facebook | Pinterest | Twitter | Instagram



Speak Your Mind

*

Comments

  1. Those look like they belong on my Thanksgiving table! Happy weekend :)

  2. These sound yummy! Will have to try these!!

  3. I need these now! PS: I must really be behind in blog reading because when did you do a site makeover? But whenever you did, it looks great!!

  4. These look incredible!

  5. mmmhmm looks perfect, I just pinned

  6. These look divine! And, for the record, I have the same nightmare about the turkey!!!

  7. YUM! I’m definitely making these! And they are so dang easy…..I love that! Thanks!

  8. These look absolutely delish!!! And the best part is – absolutely easy! Thanks for the recipe. Going to give these a try for Turkey Day and seriously cannot wait! Hmm, maybe I’ll have to make a batch before the big day 😉

  9. Prepare yourself for an early Valentine from my boys. YUM. Thank you!

  10. These sound absolutely delightful! Awesome idea!

  11. I just made these this morning. They are awesome! I’ll be bringing them to a pre-Thanksgiving playdate tomorrow.

  12. These look ABSOLUTELY heavenly!!! Yummmm!

  13. I just love a good pecan pie, but never want to put the work into it. These look awesome and so easy to do…love that gooey center!!!

  14. My grandmother loves pecans! My husband and I are flying home for Christmas, and I know she would love this little treat! Thanks for the recipe :)

  15. Love your quick and easy recipes! Made these this afternoon for a family get together. Yummy! But i subbed walnuts for pecans…still turned out fantastic!

  16. I made these for Thanksgiving and everyone loved them! Thank you for sharing!

  17. These look so moorish and you are absolutely gorgeous and your family the same.
    Are you LDS?

  18. I made these and they’re fantastic. Super easy and delicious. Will make them again! Thx!

  19. when you don’t feel like making a HUGE pie – pecan pie muffins come to the rescue. how perfect and EASY. I am all about easy baking recipes this time of year. Love this recipe Christy :)

  20. Thats it?! so easy, and I love love love pecan pie! and muffins ; D need to give these a try.

  21. Jeanine Larson says:

    Christy, I love your comments after the pictures. Were these thanksgiving food pictures taken on your back porch? I think you should share with your bloggers the truth about John carving the lean turkey with four legs. love you! Mom

  22. I just made these and they were kind of awful. They were SUPER oily, dense, and they didn’t look at all like the image. I think the recipe needs more flour and less butter and they would probably benefit from a touch a vanilla extract.

    • @Gillian,
      Sorry. I would say that they are on the dense side just like a pecan pie. I’m sorry you didn’t like them.

    • I made them also. Had the same results. The bottoms were heavy. The best part was the tops. I wont be making the again….Ill make the pie instead.

    • Kathy, just curious did you use real butter? I can kinda see where margarine and maybe even salted real butter might make them like you described.

  23. Just made these this morning for my boss— they were a hit and I’ve had two recipe request so far! Thanks for sharing.

  24. Eleanor Holler says:

    I decided to make these muffins because they didn.t have too many ingredients. I used only one stick of butter, by accident, and they still came out fabulous, they were very crunchy on the outside and soft in the middle. I used walnuts and they still were delish. It was hard to eat just one and I didn’t. I am on Weight Watchers and in case any ladies want to know they are 10 points. So I will make them definitelyl again, maybe on a cheat day or when company is coming over.
    t’

  25. I tried these pecan muffins. I used paper liners for medium muffins. I did fill them more full then suggested so I baked them longer. They did not stay together. I did cool them but when I took off the paper it fell apart. I still ate a couple and they tasted wonderful put I couldn’t serve them. What did I do wrong? Any suggestions?

    • Christy {The Girl Who Ate Everything} says:

      @Pat,
      I’m so sorry. It’s hard when I’m not actually in your kitchen to see what might have gone wrong. They may fall apart if baked too long.

  26. These look yummy? My question on these muffins and all muffins can I make them in the Jumbo muffin pans and if so how long would I bake them? Also can I use the Jumbo muffin papers on them? I prefer using the papers so people can handle them but wasn’t for sure if it would hurt. I can’t wait to make these!

    • Christy {The Girl Who Ate Everything} says:

      I haven’t ever tried to make them jumbo size. I’m not sure how long I would bake them unless I tried it…

      • Do you think it would be o.k. to use the muffin papers when I bake them?

        • Christy {The Girl Who Ate Everything} says:

          I’ve heard some people say that the paper sticks but I haven’t tried it.

          • Lynn MacDonald says:

            If you have a Dollar Tree store nearby, try their muffin cups. They’re different from regular paper muffin cups. They feel a little like sort of wax paper. They don’t stick to your muffins. I haven’t tried this recipe “yet” but they don’t stick to my other muffins or cupcakes. I LOVE THEM!!! I never buy the regular paper muffin cups anymore.

  27. Oh dear!! I have just spent the better part of my morning going through your amazing site! You have fantastic recipes. Do you think a brown sugar/pecan streusel will hold up on these? Would it be too much? Thank you in advance…and no worries about getting back promptly! Congrats on your fifth baby!!!

  28. Really easy and delicious! In my house loved them … Only aded one and half teaspoons of maple extract, and taste like a real pecan pie. The strange thing is that even than the recipe says about 16 mini muffins out, left me almost 40! Thank you for this lovely recipe and I´m sorry for my bad english!

  29. I just baked these. I followed the recipe exactly and used paper liners in the muffin tin. They turned out tasting gorgeous! They didn’t even stick to the paper lining, except at the very bottom. Definitely a winner!

  30. Wanda Mercier says:

    Have tried to print two different pecan recipes from this site. Keeps going to a ” blank page”. Help!

    • Christy {The Girl Who Ate Everything} says:

      Wanda,
      Sorry! Unfortunately I’ve contacted ziplist who does the printing and they said it’s a bug with Internet Explorer and their program. I’ve had the same problem but I’ve found if I clear my cookies it works. Also if you print from a different browser like Firefox or Safari you shouldn’t have a problem.

  31. Made these in the mini muffin pan and forgot to put the pecan halve on top. Tastes great! Taking them to tonight’s party. Don’t really get the gooey center in the minis so I’m trying the larger muffin next time.

  32. I absolutely L<3'd these:) the recipe is easy to remember and is scrumptious.
    I did add a few things to it…toasted coconut flakes, vanilla, dash of salt, and a few tablespoons of flour.
    Thank you!

    Everyone who tried it loved it! Needless to say, it didn't last long!

  33. Have you tried these with gluten flour? If so did they turn out? They look wonderful & so easy! Thanks for the recipe!

    • Christy {The Girl Who Ate Everything} says:

      I haven’t tried them with gluten free flour so I can’t say if it would work. Anyone else tried it?

  34. I made these tonight and I’m so very happy I did…OH MY! So yummy. Making these for Thanksgiving for sure!

  35. Hi, you mentioned above that they are wonderful if you under-bake them and I was wondering if the cook time you listed reflects that or if I need to shave a few minutes off of that? Thank you!

  36. Alicia vargas says:

    excellent recipe. super easy to make and fast. leave about 10 minutes more for cooking and were perfect. thanks for sharing. should be within the top

  37. Elaine Johnson says:

    Just finding your site. Love anything with pecans in it. Can’t wait to try the Pecan Pie Muffins. They sure look good. Was looking at some of your other recipes, and they look delicious too.

  38. I think these are going in the oven tonight. Sounds so yummy.

  39. GOOD Pecan Pie is my very favorite so I’m sure I’d like these. However the runny part of the pie is what I like best so don’t know if this would work for sure. NOTICE: I said GOOD pecan pie——-they’re not all in that category but I usually try it out anyway.

  40. I tied these but added 1 cup of flour and uses the dollar tree muffin cups. Worked great. I like it better with a bit more flour and I used walnuts in place of pecans.

  41. I can’t wait to try these.

  42. Will have to try these

  43. if you want to make it class end of school gifts or for a bake sale use foil cup liners and skip the grease

  44. Will be trying this recipe

  45. Mary Sutterby says:

    Only 1/2 cup flour ?

  46. they look yummy i will try this recipe.

  47. I am making these as we speak! I noticed the recipe says it will make 16 mini muffins. I have a mini tin that holds 24 and it filled it and I still have some left! Must be different size minis?

  48. These muffins look soooooo good. I am goin

  49. These Muffins look soooooo delicious….I am going to have to try these. Thanks so much.
    Peggy Fowler

  50. Barbara Marler says:

    Pecan muffins looks so good, I will be trying these!

  51. Harriett Adams says:

    This look yummy. I am going to make some for my family. Sure to be a hit. Thanks for the recipe. Will let you know how they turn out.

  52. I checked out the original recipe on Allrecipes.com and the only difference I seen was that you doubled the pecans. Not that I disagree, but can I ask you what you didn’t like about the one with only 1 cup of pecans? Other than more crunch, did it make them less gooey or something? Just curious before I attempt to make one or the other recipe, as pecans are kind of expensive and I’d like to choose the recipe I think I would enjoy better! *I usually make mini-muffins. Thanks!

  53. Terri lombardo says:

    I will definitely be trying these

  54. I tried making these tonight, and made them exactly as the recipe stated and thoroughly greased the regular muffin tins. They would not stay together enough to get out of the muffin tins. I found other similar pecan pie muffins on some other sites that only used 1 cup of chopped pecans. I don’t know if that was the problem or not. I was disappointed as I wasted good ingredients on these. We tried eating them with a spoon and they had a good flavor, but something is wrong with this recipe.

  55. I am going grocery shopping tomorrow and since I already have all of the ingredients except the brown sugar, I can afford a test run before Thanksgiving! Thanks for sharing!

  56. So I read some comments, and decided to modify the recipe. I added some gnd flaxseeds, couple Tb of wheat flour, pecans and walnuts, 2t vanilla, threw it in my bundt pan and baked at 375 for 25 min till pulled away from sides. It was a bit hard to release from pan, it was not gooey but delicious. I am going to double the recipe next time, which will be soon. it ls even better after it sits overnight covered withi plastic wrap which seemed to bind it better. It was scruptious…….

  57. Just made, ohhh let me tell u! Thank u!

  58. I made these Pecan Pie Muffins two weeks ago to take to my Mom’s house. They are delicious. My husband loved them. I plan to make some today for us and again on Saturday for a birthday party. They will be a hit!. Thanks so much for an easy, delicious recipe. Rose

  59. I have got to make these, because they look awesome.

  60. Looks great and I love to cook. Can’t wait to try them.

  61. Roxanne Wilde says:

    i make these every year for my Christmas party. Cut horizontally in half, spread with Poupon mustard, place a slice of smoked ham and a piece of lettuce. Secure with toothpick. The sweet and savory favors blend perfectly. One year I didn’t make these for my party and there was a revolt. These have become a tradition at my parties.

  62. Could these be made into a cake?

  63. Frances Morey says:

    I would like to try this with 1 cup of date sugar, half cup of almond flour (or tapioca flour), of course the pecans and the equivalent of two eggs in egg whites only. There is no vegan substitute for butter. Can’t wait to try my version–I do love both muffins and pecan pie.

  64. I found this recipe on Facebook. I made them for the 4th of July and they were definitely a huge hit with everyone! I didn’t change a thing..well maybe a few more pecans..love my nuts.lol Anyway the only issue I had was I didn’t make enough. Next time I will double or triple the recipe. So whoever shared this…thank you so much! I will make these all the time. Don’t be afraid to make these simple easy and oh so delicious!

  65. I Made these little guys there are Just My family was fighting over the last one making more tonight one family AT A TIME :) I added1/2 tsp. salt, 1 tsp. vanilla, 1cup of butter